
Notice I am not in this picture but I can assure you, my dress was as close to these as I could possibly get. No risk taking for fashion in the 8th Grade.
The 8th Grade Dinner Dance was the biggest thing I could imagine to end my tenure as a middle schooler. We didn’t all take dates but we did get dressed up in what our mothers would have called our Sunday best but we might have called our I’m not a child any more dress. It needed to be just sweet enough to satisfy our parents and just sleazy enough to attract the attention of the boys and the jealousy of the girls. In hindsight, it occurs to me that not much changed as we selected new outfits for high school, college and even adult events.
But the lesson isn’t in the dress or even the balance between sweet and sleazy. My lesson began with the search for the dress. Or more specifically, who was going to search for the dress.
As a teenager, I had my own opinions on style and fashion and, like most teens, these clashed with my mother’s (someday I’ll share the story of the leg warmer war of 1982). So when it came time to begin the search, we’d already had a few arguments as a lead up. Then my crafty and wise mother presented me with an option.
On a sunny Saturday morning she pulled from her wallet a JCPenney credit card. I had seen the card before and I had heard the credit cards are bad speech a few times so I’m sure I let out a small gasp upon its appearance. I was scheduled to go to the mall with friends that day and had agreed to look at dresses and if I found one I really liked we would go back and consider it together. Which I knew meant, I could try it on, mom would say no, find the most horribly baby-fied dress in the store and make me accept it or go home with nothing and be forced to re-wear something I had worn to church already. Horrifying. I’m sure I shuttered at the thought. So when she presented the JCPenney card I was intrigued.
My mother, crafty sly dog that she was, made an eloquent speech about responsibility and trust and consequences and lots of other mom-talk that sounded a lot like Charlie Brown’s teacher until she ended with, ” So I’m giving you this card for today and trusting that you will use it wisely.”. Wait, what? I asked for a review of the speech, certain I had missed some key point that included something like “and so you will never again be allowed to use the phone or walk outside or you will have to take your brother with you to the dance”. Surely she wasn’t just handing over a credit card to a 13-year-old with only the “use it wisely” advice. The review covered the rules:
- I must select a dress style that my parents would approve of me wearing.
- I must consider the cost of the dress and use good judgement not to waste the family’s money.
- I must only purchase a dress; no shoes, no purse, no accessories of any kind.
- If I followed the rules, I could not only keep the dress, I would be given the chance again to use her credit card for other purchases.
- If I broke the rules, I could keep the dress but I would NEVER AGAIN be trusted with the credit card.
(Keep in mind this was 1983 when you could still use your parent’s credit card at a store without being questioned.)
I was ecstatic. My friends were amazed. Our ride to the mall was in some kind of teenage shoppers high, giddy with the thought that we had infinite money and the freedom to make a choice with no parental input. I floated through the doors of the store and began to tear through the racks to find whatever the hell I wanted thank you. It was awesome.
For a bit.
And then it sucked. The weight of the responsibility began to wear on me more than the dresses I was trying on. Quickly I was discounting dresses on the rack that I would have begged to try on and pleaded to buy had my mom been there. Too short. Too revealing. Too expensive-what is that dress made of, gold? I swore I heard mom’s voice in my head checking off the reasons that certain dresses should be pushed aside. I suddenly realized she had played a cruel trick on me. With no one to plead with by my conscience, I was slowly tiring of the joy of this freedom and felt burdened by the possible consequences of my behavior.
I found a dress that day. Conservative but pretty and well within what I assumed was a fair price. I cautiously slipped into it at home and modelled it for my parents along with presenting the receipt. They were pleased, satisfied with the style and the cost. Mom decided I would need shoes to go with it and probably a nice necklace would complement the neckline. Crafty that Kay, very crafty.
Later she revealed her lesson to me. She wanted me to learn responsibility and consequence. She didn’t know if I would succeed or fail, although she was pulling for me. My mother’s lessons on trust involved giving someone the chance to be trusted and then accepting their actions without further judgement. Either they showed you they were worthy, or not. Either way, you knew what you were dealing with. Mom wanted to see if I had taken a step toward critical thinking and self-control. She needed to know as I prepared to enter high school, if I could be trusted to make decisions based on what I had been taught by her.
I didn’t always make the right choice. Many times throughout high school and beyond, she would glare through me or, worse, be so disappointed that she couldn’t look at me at all. God, that was the worst. Mom didn’t mind if you screwed up something you didn’t know, but if you deliberately made a choice to defy or ignore what you knew was right, that was going to be a long recovery. That was a credit card you would not soon see again.
Spiderman’s Uncle Ben said, “With great power, comes great responsibility”. My mother would suggest that it goes both ways; being responsible can grant you much power. It’s a lesson I’ve tried to show my own children over and over. It’s a lesson I try hard to remember for myself.
I used my mom’s credit card a few more times in my youth, each time it became easier to manage. Looking back, I see lots of times my brother and I were subjected to some other crafty check on our development. That Kay, she was sly.
My guess is she also felt the same burden that at times makes it difficult for me to breathe. As a parent to three young men, I have some mom power. With that, though, I have a responsibility to raise them. Which means lots of behavioral development experiments that their dad and I perform on them pulling for their success, but aware that failure is an option.
Credit cards. Cell phones. Social media. Cars. It’s all a test, really, to see if they are prepared to live with the consequences of their choices. I thought it was terrifying to buy the dress in 83; now I realize it had to be a really long day for my mom, wondering if I would succeed or fail. I know the relief on her face that day was not because the dress was all-right but because I was all-right.
Power and responsibility. Right and privilege. Lessons for my kids, yes; but no less Lessons from 40Something.